Explainer | Who makes China’s stimulus decisions, and what’s the procedure?

What has changed since China rolled out a 4-trillion-yuan stimulus package in 2008, and why a concrete stimulus figure now remains elusive

Reading Time:3 minutes

Some market players in China have voiced disappointment at the lack of a fiscal stimulus figure. Photo: Bloomberg

Published: 7:10pm, 14 Oct 2024Updated: 11:57am, 16 Oct 2024

In recent weeks, expectations of China unleashing a major stimulus reached a crescendo as the top brass of China’s major economic ministries and commissions took turns appearing on stage in the State Council’s press conference hall.

After an initial larger-than-expected monetary package unveiled in the last week of September, some market players voiced disappointment at the absence of substantial moves by the nation’s top economic planner and the lack of a fiscal stimulus figure.

With Beijing’s stimulus plans under way, a closer look at the decision-making procedure in China’s political system may help explain why the ministries have been tight-lipped.

03:49

Rally cry by Xi sets economic priorities for Chinese officials, absolves them of mistakes

Who decides China’s stimulus packages?

Compared with the 2008 stimulus package announced by China’s then premier, Wen Jiabao, China’s current economic power now largely rests with the Central Financial and Economic Affairs Commission headed by President Xi Jinping.

And in the past decade, the top leadership has shunned all-out stimulus measures. The 4-trillion-yuan stimulus package rolled out in late 2008 was thought to have brought a variety of problems, including industrial overcapacity, a mountain of local-level debt through financing vehicles, heavy reliance on the property market, and rampant risk in the financial system.

Instead, they have preferred more targeted measures in trying to resolve the structural problems faced by the world’s second-largest economy.

But their tone changed when the Politburo, the centre of power within the Communist Party headed by Xi, convened an unexpected economy-centric meeting on September 26 and issued a rallying call to mobilise officials across the nation to prioritise reviving the economy, in a bid to achieve leadership’s annual growth target of “around 5 per cent”.